Portrait of Franklin S. Spalding

Episcopal bishop of Utah

Franklin S. Spalding

1865–1914

1 topic · 1 dated event · 1 source

Their part in each topic

The Book of Abraham and the Joseph Smith Papyri

Episcopal bishop of Utah

In 1912 Spalding mailed the three facsimiles to eight Egyptologists and Assyriologists — Sayce, Petrie, Breasted, Mace, Peters, Mercer, Meyer and von Bissing — and published their replies as 'Joseph Smith, Jr., As a Translator.' He reported that 'in no case did one man know the opinion of another' and that agreement among them was practically complete. He is not to be confused with Solomon Spalding of the Book of Mormon authorship theory.

Timeline · Key players · Key sources · Why it matters

In the timeline

1 events across 1 topics, chronological. Only events this person was actually part of — present at, responsible for, or the subject of — not every event where the name comes up.

1912

Spalding's survey of eight Egyptologistshinge

Bishop Franklin S. Spalding published the replies of eight scholars to whom he had sent the facsimiles, reporting that 'in no case did one man know the opinion of another.' Sayce called the work an impudent fraud; Petrie wrote that 'there is not one single word that is true in these explanations.' Latter-day Saint replies in the Improvement Era attacked the survey's method rather than its Egyptology.

Why this is a hingeIt is the first time the church's translation claim was tested by outside experts, and B. H. Roberts conceded there were then no Egyptian scholars in the church who could answer them.
Disputed Nibley argued the panel was prejudiced by Spalding's framing; Ritner replied that their 1912 assessments 'remain valid in 2001.'
People: Franklin S. Spalding

Sources in their own name

Source records in the database whose author line names this person. Each links to the topic that uses it.

1912

Joseph Smith, Jr., As a Translator

Franklin S. Spalding

Secondary sourceScholarlyText held in the Corpus

The first organized expert test of the facsimiles, and the exact wording of the judgments by Sayce, Petrie, Breasted, Mace, Peters, Mercer, Meyer and von Bissing.

This page is generated from the same topic records as the rest of the database, so a correction made once shows up here too. All key players · How this is built