1833–1857

Violence and the Mormon Conflict

Missouri, the Danites, and the Nauvoo Expositor, 1833–1844

21 sources, ordered by evidentiary weight — primary and contemporary first, then documentary editions, then the argument. 18 of them are held as full text in the Mormon Corpus; the other 3 are reached only as quotations inside works that are held, and are marked.

1838

Executive Order of Lilburn W. Boggs, 27 October 1838 (Missouri Executive Order 44), copied in JS Letterbook 2

Lilburn W. Boggs

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusThe Joseph Smith Papers, Letterbook 2, full transcript; also copied into History, 1838–1856, volume B-1.

The exact wording and the stated grounds of the extermination order, and that it was issued to General John B. Clark as a military order.

1838

Oration Delivered by Mr. S. Rigdon on the 4th of July, 1838, at Far West, Caldwell County, Missouri (Far West: Journal Office)

Sidney Rigdon

Primary source Primary Not held — reached at second handNOT held as a work. The twelve-page pamphlet — the only book printed on the Mormon press at Far West — is quoted at length in MormonThink, BYU Studies, JMH, Sunstone, Vogel and the Church's own history topic essay, and reprinted photographically in BYU Studies 14 (1974).

The 'war of extermination' language, published and circulated with Joseph Smith's endorsement four months before Boggs used the same word.

1838

Elders' Journal of the Church of Latter Day Saints (1837–1838)

Joseph Smith, editor

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusFull run in the periodicals collection; the August 1838 issue (p. 54) carries the editorial endorsement of Rigdon's oration.

That the Fourth of July oration was not a rogue speech: the church's own paper, edited by Smith, recommended that members obtain the pamphlet.

1838

Journal, March–September 1838

Joseph Smith

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusThe Joseph Smith Papers, full transcript; the 27 July 1838 Danite passage was cancelled in the original manuscript and is best read alongside Faulring's edition.

Smith's contemporaneous, favorable reference to 'a company of Danites' — the strongest primary evidence that he knew of and approved the band.

1839–1846

Times and Seasons, vols. 1–6

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusFull run in the periodicals collection — the whole paper, not the selected extracts the Joseph Smith Papers carry.

The church's own serialized 'History of the Persecution' in Missouri, including Joseph Young's Hawn's Mill affidavit and Edward Partridge's account of being tarred in 1833.

1841

Document Containing the Correspondence, Orders, &c., in Relation to the Disturbances with the Mormons (Fayette, Mo.: Boon's Lick Democrat)

Missouri General Assembly

Primary source Primary Not held — reached at second handNOT held. The state's printed compilation of the Richmond testimony and the militia correspondence is the ur-text for Avard's testimony, Marsh's affidavit and the extermination order; the corpus reaches it only through reproductions (Tanner, Bushman, Turner, BYU Studies, JMH).

The Missouri government's own assembled evidentiary record of the 1838 war — the single document most quoted by every camp in this dispute.

1844

Nauvoo Expositor, 7 June 1844 (the single issue)

William Law, Wilson Law, Charles Ivins, Francis M. Higbee, Chauncey L. Higbee, Robert D. Foster, Charles A. Foster

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusEarly Latter-day Saint and Restorationist periodicals collection — the complete four-page issue. The page images are heavily OCR-garbled; a clean transcription of the same text is reproduced by FAIR as 'Primary sources/Nauvoo Expositor Full Text'.

Exactly what the dissenters charged in print — plural marriage, the plurality of gods, political revelation, and the Nauvoo charter — in their own words, three days before the press was destroyed.

1844

Nauvoo Neighbor (1843–1845)

John Taylor, editor

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusFull run in the periodicals collection; the 17 June 1844 issue carries the city's own published account of the removal of the Expositor.

How the Nauvoo leadership justified the abatement publicly within a week of the act, expressly invoking the destruction of their own press in Jackson County.

1854–1886

Journal of Discourses, vols. 1–26

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusComplete, full text, volume-addressable. Volume 4 carries the September–November 1856 Reformation sermons of Brigham Young and Jedediah M. Grant.

The Utah-era blood-atonement rhetoric in its published form, and Brigham Young's later public dismissal of the Danite legend.

1839

A Brief History of the Church of Christ of Latter Day Saints

John Corrill

Primary source Contemporary Text held in the CorpusThe Joseph Smith Papers holds the full transcript, with the editors' historical introduction filed separately as neutral-academic.

A participant-dissenter's description, written within months, of the Danite covenant, the Salt Sermon, and why he could neither defect nor object once the community had militarized.

1838

Minutes and Testimonies, 12–29 November 1838 [State of Missouri v. Gates et al. for Treason]

Primary source Documentary edition Text held in the CorpusThe Joseph Smith Papers, full transcript of the surviving Richmond court-of-inquiry record, with the editors' introduction as a separate work.

Sworn testimony taken within weeks of the events — including Reed Peck on the Salt Sermon and on Avard's teaching — and the commitment orders naming who was charged with what.

1844

Revised Minutes, 17 June 1844 [synopsis of Nauvoo City Council proceedings, 8 and 10 June 1844]

Primary source Documentary edition Text held in the CorpusThe Joseph Smith Papers, full transcript.

The council debate itself: who said what about libel, nuisance, Blackstone and the charter before the vote to abate.

2014

Gospel Topics essay, "Peace and Violence among 19th-Century Latter-day Saints"

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Official LDS Official Not held — reached at second handThe essay's own text did not surface as a held work in this corpus; its wording is reproduced and answered at length by FAIR and by MormonThink, which is how it is quoted here.

The Church's formal position that Smith approved of the Danites but probably was not briefed on all their plans.

2018

Saints: The Story of the Church of Jesus Christ in the Latter Days, vol. 1, chs. 27–31

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Official LDS Official Text held in the CorpusFull text of the Church's current official narrative history.

What the institution now tells its own members about the Salt Sermon, the Danites, Avard's testimony and the extermination order.

2005

Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling

Richard Lyman Bushman with Jed Woodworth

Nuanced Scholarly Text held in the CorpusFull text.

The standard believing-scholarly reconstruction, including the evidentiary gap at Gallatin and Smith's ambiguous position during the fighting.

2014

"Race, Violence, and the Mormon War," Journal of Mormon History 40/1

T. Ward Frampton

Neutral academic Scholarly Text held in the CorpusJournal of Mormon History collection, full issue.

The Gallatin election-day fight and Hawn's Mill in their Missouri racial and frontier-violence context, with the contemporary accounts collated.

2025

Joseph Smith: The Rise and Fall of an American Prophet

John G. Turner

Neutral academic Scholarly Text held in the CorpusFull text.

A recent non-confessional narrative of the Daviess raids, Crooked River and the surrender, using militia correspondence and participant diaries.

"Turning Type into Pi: The Destruction of the Nauvoo Expositor in Historical Context"

Craig L. Foster

Faithful / apologetic Apologetic Text held in the CorpusInterpreter Foundation, article text.

The apologetic case that press destruction was a recurrent feature of 1830s–40s American politics rather than a Mormon anomaly.

1974

"The Danite Band of 1838," BYU Studies 14/4

Leland H. Gentry

Nuanced Apologetic Text held in the CorpusBYU Studies collection, article text.

The classic faithful reading: a three-stage Danite history in which Avard corrupted a defensive brotherhood without the First Presidency's knowledge.

1969

The Mormon Kingdom, Volume 1

Jerald and Sandra Tanner

Evangelical counter-cult Critical Text held in the CorpusUtah Lighthouse Ministry collection, full text; reproduces long stretches of the 1841 Missouri Document and of the Reed Peck manuscript.

Verbatim reproductions of the Danite oath, Avard's testimony and Marsh's affidavit — valuable as a finding aid, adversarial in framing.

2023

Charisma under Pressure

Dan Vogel

Critical / secular Critical Text held in the CorpusFull text (advance reading copy).

The most document-dense critical reconstruction of the Danite organization, the Fourth of July oration and the Richmond hearing, with the underlying testimony quoted at length.

What this topic needs that the corpus does not hold

  • Document Containing the Correspondence, Orders, &c., in Relation to the Disturbances with the Mormons (Fayette, Mo., 1841) — the Missouri legislature's printed compilation of the Richmond testimony and militia correspondence, and the ur-text for Avard's testimony, Marsh's affidavit and the extermination order. Not held; reached only through reproductions.
  • Sidney Rigdon's Oration Delivered by Mr. S. Rigdon on the 4th of July, 1838 — the pamphlet itself is not held as a work, only quoted.
  • Stephen C. LeSueur, The 1838 Mormon War in Missouri (1987), and Alexander L. Baugh, A Call to Arms (2000) — the two book-length modern accounts around which the entire historiographical dispute turns; neither is held, though the argument between them is visible in JMH, Sunstone and BYU Studies.
  • The Reed Peck manuscript and John D. Lee's Mormonism Unveiled as standalone texts; both are quoted only through Tanner and other reproductions.
  • The Gospel Topics essay 'Peace and Violence among 19th-Century Latter-day Saints' as its own work; its text is reached only through FAIR's and MormonThink's reproductions.

Related topics

People who also appear elsewhere