Portrait of Sidney Rigdon

First Presidency counselor and orator

Sidney Rigdon

1793–1876

2 topics · 16 dated events · 2 sources

Their part in each topic

Violence and the Mormon Conflict

First Presidency counselor and orator

Rigdon preached the 17 June 1838 "Salt Sermon" against the Far West dissenters and delivered the Fourth of July oration that threatened "a war of extermination" against any mob. He is the presumed author of the letter ordering the dissenters out of Caldwell County. Later Latter-day Saint leaders, Brigham Young among them, blamed him personally for provoking the Missouri conflict.

Timeline · Key players · Key sources · Why it matters

The Succession Crisis of 1844

First Presidency counselor

The last surviving member of the First Presidency and Joseph Smith's vice-presidential running mate, sent to Pittsburgh nine days before the martyrdom. He hurried back and asked the Saints to appoint him 'guardian' of the church, not its president, on the theory that the church could only ever be built up to the dead prophet. Beaten on 8 August and excommunicated on 8 September, he organized his own church in Pittsburgh and argued his case in his own newspaper for two years.

Timeline · Key players · Key sources · Why it matters

In the timeline

16 events across 2 topics, chronological. Only events this person was actually part of — present at, responsible for, or the subject of — not every event where the name comes up.

17 June 1838

Rigdon's "Salt Sermon"

Preaching on salt that has lost its savour and is fit only to be cast out and trodden underfoot, Sidney Rigdon attacked the dissenters without naming them. John Corrill wrote that it was plainly understood whom he meant. Reed Peck testified at Richmond that Rigdon said in the same sermon that he would assist to erect a gallows on the square and hang them all.

Disputed Peck's recollection of the gallows line comes from a hostile witness under oath months later; no text of the sermon survives.
People: Sidney Rigdon
June 1838

The dissenters' letter orders five men out of the county

A long letter, presumably written by Rigdon and signed by eighty-three men, was delivered to Oliver Cowdery, David Whitmer, John Whitmer, W. W. Phelps and Lyman Johnson the day after the Salt Sermon. It accused them of joining "a band of counterfeiters, thieves, liars, and blacklegs of the deepest dye" and closed: "We will put you from the county of Caldwell, so help us God." The families left, and their property was attached.

Disputed John Whitmer alleged the dissenters were also threatened with death; the signers' letter itself threatens only expulsion.
People: Sidney Rigdon
4 July 1838

Rigdon's Fourth of July oration at Far Westhinge

At a celebration that laid the temple cornerstones and paraded the Caldwell militia and a company of Danites, Rigdon declared that if a mob came against the Saints "it shall be between us and them a war of extermination, for we will follow them till the last drop of blood is spilled, or else they will have to exterminate us." The oration was printed as a pamphlet on the Far West press and reprinted in Missouri papers.

Why this is a hingeIt put the word 'extermination' into public circulation on the Mormon side four months before Boggs used it, and Missourians cited it thereafter as proof of Mormon intent.
Disputed Ebenezer Robinson said the oration was a prepared document understood by the whole First Presidency; Rigdon's own later testimony described the offending line as a brief closing remark that was misreported.
People: Sidney Rigdon
31 October – 1 November 1838

Far West surrenders; Doniphan refuses to execute the prisoners

Colonel George M. Hinkle brought Joseph Smith and other leaders into the militia camp, where they were taken prisoner. A militia court-martial sentenced them to be shot the next morning; General Doniphan refused to carry out the order, calling the proceeding illegal. Far West surrendered its arms and the inhabitants signed away property to cover the cost of the campaign.

Disputed Corrill and Peck said Smith was eager to sue for peace; Latter-day Saint accounts stress Hinkle's betrayal.
12–29 November 1838

The Richmond court of inquiry; Avard testifies

Judge Austin A. King heard evidence for more than two weeks against some sixty defendants. Sampson Avard, captured and threatened with prosecution, was the state's chief witness; he called Joseph Smith "the prime mover and organizer of this Danite band" and produced a Danite constitution. King found probable cause against thirty-four men. Smith, his brother Hyrum, Rigdon, Wight, McRae and Baldwin were held for treason.

Disputed Latter-day Saint petitioners in 1839 said Avard "swore false concerning a constitution"; no other witness claimed to have seen the document before he produced it.
People: Sampson Avard · Joseph Smith Jr. · Hyrum Smith · Sidney Rigdon · Lyman Wight
1 December 1838

Liberty Jail

Six prisoners were confined in a two-level limestone jail measuring about fourteen feet square, mostly in the cold lower room lit by two grated openings. They petitioned unsuccessfully for habeas corpus; only Rigdon was released. Meanwhile the body of the church left Missouri for Illinois through the winter.

People: Joseph Smith Jr. · Hyrum Smith · Sidney Rigdon · Lyman Wight
18 June 1844

Rigdon leaves for Pittsburgh; a letter is later dated to this day

The Rigdon family boarded the steamer Osprey for Pittsburgh, sent there partly to establish residency for the vice-presidential ticket and partly, according to Joseph Smith's diary, to get Rigdon out of danger. James J. Strang would later publish a letter dated the same day in which Joseph appointed him to plant a stake in Wisconsin and, Strangites held, named him successor. Strang further claimed that on 27 June, the day of the martyrdom, an angel ordained him a prophet, seer, revelator and translator, and that the letter reached him by mail on 9 July.

Disputed Strang's Letter of Appointment is regarded as a forgery by LDS and most academic historians; Strangites regard it as genuine, and even among Strang's own family its wording was read as appointing him only over the Voree stake.
People: Sidney Rigdon · Joseph Smith Jr. · James J. Strang
3–4 August 1844

Sidney Rigdon returns to Nauvoo

Rigdon arrived from Pittsburgh, declined a request from Willard Richards, Parley P. Pratt and George A. Smith to meet with them, and preached at Sunday services instead. He told the Saints it was the Lord's wish that a guardian be appointed to build up the church to Joseph, and asked William Marks to call a special assembly. Marks announced it for the morning of 8 August.

Disputed Accounts date the arrival to 3 or 4 August; Newell and Avery place Brigham Young's arrival at 6 August, by which time Rigdon was already claiming authority.
People: Sidney Rigdon · William Marks
7 August 1844

The confrontation in the Seventies Hall

With nine apostles now in Nauvoo, Brigham Young convened the Twelve, the Nauvoo High Council and the high priests and asked Rigdon to state his case. Rigdon described a Pittsburgh manifestation shown to his mind rather than an open vision: no man could be Joseph's successor, and he would continue to speak for the dead prophet until Joseph descended and ordained him. Young replied that he did not care who led the church of God if God said so, but that he must know God said so, and that he had the keys and means of knowing.

People: Brigham Young · Sidney Rigdon
8 August 1844 (morning)

Rigdon speaks in the grove

Thousands gathered in the grove near the temple. Rigdon stood in a wagon with his back to a steady wind and spoke for more than an hour, arguing that every man would stand in his own place and calling, that Joseph and Hyrum held their authority through eternity, and that authority remained in the church as Joseph had organized it. Thomas Bullock took the sermon down in Taylor shorthand; it was not deciphered until the twenty-first century. Brigham Young then called the congregation back for the afternoon.

People: Sidney Rigdon · Brigham Young
8 August 1844 (afternoon)

The Saints vote for the Twelvehinge

The quorums took their places as in a solemn assembly. Brigham Young told the congregation that the Quorum of the Twelve held the keys of the kingdom of God in all the world and that no man could put another between the Twelve and the prophet Joseph. He asked whether the Saints wanted a guardian, a prophet or a spokesman; the church's own report says not a hand was raised. On the motion to sustain the Twelve, Woodruff later wrote, 'At once there was a sea of hands, a universal vote; a contrary vote was called and not a hand was raised in a congregation of about fifteen thousand Saints.'

Why this is a hingeFor the only time in the movement's history, the leadership of the church was settled by a show of hands.
Disputed Van Wagoner reads the vote as a political victory won by an organized quorum over a sick and rambling rival; Jorgensen and Addams read it as the congregation recognizing a spiritual witness.
People: Brigham Young · Sidney Rigdon · Wilford Woodruff
8 September 1844

Sidney Rigdon is tried and excommunicatedhinge

Before a congregation the Nauvoo Neighbor reported at six to seven thousand, Brigham Young laid out what he called Rigdon's secret plan to divide the church, and testified that Rigdon had ordained men prophets, priests and kings at private meetings. Rigdon was in St. Louis and did not attend. Bishop Newel K. Whitney and the high council voted to cut him off; W. W. Phelps moved that he be delivered over to the buffetings of Satan until he repents. About ten hands were raised for Rigdon. Two days later he left for Pittsburgh.

Why this is a hingeThis is the moment the crisis stopped being a contest inside one church and became a schism.
Disputed Rigdon's paper answered that the Twelve had determined to supplant him before the church ever acted, so the trial ratified a decision already made.
People: Sidney Rigdon · Brigham Young
15 October 1844

Rigdon's own paper begins in Pittsburgh

Within a month of reaching Pittsburgh, Rigdon had organized a church with himself as First President and launched the Latter Day Saints' Messenger and Advocate, reusing the name of the old Kirtland organ. Its first number carried his signed statement to the public and letters describing conditions in Nauvoo. Over the next two years it argued the succession case in print, branch resolutions and all.

People: Sidney Rigdon
December 1844

William Marks repudiates Rigdon in print

Marks published a notice in the Times and Seasons saying that after mature and candid deliberation he was convinced Rigdon's claims to the presidency were not founded in truth, that he had been deceived by specious pretences, and that the Twelve were the proper persons to lead the church. He warned everyone under his influence against Rigdon's pretended visions and revelations.

People: William Marks · Sidney Rigdon
January 1845

Rigdon turns on Joseph Smith

Rigdon stopped emphasizing his own guardianship and began accusing Joseph Smith of having been a fallen prophet, principally over plural marriage. About forty per cent of the Philadelphia branch was excommunicated between September 1844 and 1847, most for rejecting apostolic succession; a number of those converts signed for Rigdon, then for Strang, then rejected Strang too.

People: Sidney Rigdon

Sources in their own name

Source records in the database whose author line names this person. Each links to the topic that uses it.

1844

Latter Day Saints' Messenger and Advocate (Pittsburgh, 1844–1846)

Sidney Rigdon

Primary sourcePrimaryText held in the Corpus

The losing claimant's case in his own words: the scriptural argument from Doctrine and Covenants 90 that Rigdon was commanded to preside, the charge that the Twelve had decided to supplant him before the church ever voted, and branch-by-branch resolutions repudiating the Twelve.

Appears alongside

People who share the most dated events with Sidney Rigdon.

This page is generated from the same topic records as the rest of the database, so a correction made once shows up here too. All key players · How this is built