1852–1907

Utah Polygamy and the Manifesto

From the 1852 announcement to the 1904 Second Manifesto

20 sources, ordered by evidentiary weight — primary and contemporary first, then documentary editions, then the argument. 19 of them are held as full text in the Mormon Corpus; the other 1 are reached only as quotations inside works that are held, and are marked.

1843, 1890

Doctrine and Covenants: section 132 and Official Declaration 1, with the appended excerpts from three addresses by Wilford Woodruff

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusCurrent LDS standard works, verse-addressable, held in the corpus.

The canonized text of the plural-marriage revelation, the exact wording of the Manifesto, Lorenzo Snow's sustaining motion of 6 October 1890, and Woodruff's later 'shown me by vision' explanations as the church itself prints them.

1852

Journal of Discourses, vol. 1 — "Celestial Marriage," discourse by Orson Pratt, Great Salt Lake City, 29 August 1852

Orson Pratt

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusThe Journal of Discourses is held complete and volume-addressable (26 vols., 1854–1886); the discourse occupies JD 1:53–66.

The wording and argument of the first public defense of plural marriage, including Pratt's opening that the subject was 'rather new ground' and his denial that the doctrine existed to gratify carnal lusts.

1866

Journal of Discourses, vol. 11 — discourse by Brigham Young, 19 August 1866

Brigham Young

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusJournal of Discourses held complete; the passage is JD 11:268–69.

The most contested nineteenth-century statement tying plural marriage to exaltation, in the surrounding context that both camps argue over.

1887, 1890

Edmunds–Tucker Act (24 Stat. 635, 1887) and Late Corporation of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints v. United States (136 U.S. 1, 1890)

United States Congress; U.S. Supreme Court

Primary source Primary Not held — reached at second handNot held as texts. Sections of the act and the opinion are reproduced inside B. H. Roberts Foundation citation records, which are index entries, not the documents.

The statutory machinery of disincorporation, escheat of church property above $50,000, and the withdrawal of the vote from all Utah women.

1904

Official Statement (the "Second Manifesto"), Joseph F. Smith, general conference, 6 April 1904

Joseph F. Smith

Primary source Primary Text held in the CorpusRetrieved verbatim this session; reproduced in full in Conference Report, October 1918, and in the B. H. Roberts Foundation records.

The exact prohibitory language, including the threat of excommunication, and its reference back to Woodruff's declaration.

1880–1970

Conference Reports of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, 1880–1970

Official LDS Contemporary Text held in the CorpusFull semiannual proceedings held verbatim; April 1906, April 1911 and October 1918 were consulted this session.

The church's own conference-floor record, including the 1906 announcement of the Taylor and Cowley resignations and later restatements of the Manifesto's scope.

1997

In the World: The Diaries of Reed Smoot

Reed Smoot, ed. Harvard S. Heath

Primary source Documentary edition Text held in the CorpusSignature Books edition held in full text; the corpus's primary window on the Smoot hearings from inside.

How the hearings looked to the man on trial and to church leaders corresponding with him, including apostolic discussion of new polygamy cases as late as 1909.

2014

Gospel Topics essay, "Plural Marriage and Families in Early Utah"

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Official LDS Official Text held in the CorpusThe eleven Gospel Topics essays are held in full text.

The institution's current statement on how widely plural marriage was lived, on divorce and remarriage, and on women's ages at marriage.

2014

Gospel Topics essay, "The Manifesto and the End of Plural Marriage"

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Official LDS Official Text held in the CorpusHeld in full text.

The church's own acknowledgement that new plural marriages were performed after 1890, that Joseph F. Smith cohabited and fathered children after 1890, and that the Second Manifesto made the first one prohibitory.

2020, 2022

Saints: The Story of the Church of Jesus Christ in the Latter Days, vols. 2–3

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Official LDS Official Text held in the CorpusAll four Saints volumes are held in full text with their chapter notes.

The church's current narrative telling of the indignation meetings, the raids, Rudger Clawson's sentencing, the Smoot hearings and the Taylor–Cowley resignations.

1985

"LDS Church Authority and New Plural Marriages, 1890–1904," Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 18, no. 1 (Spring 1985): 9–105

D. Michael Quinn

Nuanced Scholarly Text held in the CorpusDialogue is held effectively complete, 1966 to the present, as scanned issues.

The documented count and authorization pattern of post-Manifesto plural marriages, and the sequence of public denials issued alongside them.

1988

"The Prosecutions Begin: Defining Cohabitation in 1885," Dialogue 21, no. 1 (Spring 1988)

Ken Driggs

Nuanced Scholarly Text held in the CorpusHeld in the Dialogue run; the same issue carries a case-by-case list of the antipolygamy litigation.

That mass prosecutions followed the Edmunds Act and the 1885 Angus M. Cannon cohabitation ruling rather than Reynolds itself.

1991

"In Their Own Behalf: The Politicization of Mormon Women and the 1870 Franchise," Dialogue 24, no. 4 (Winter 1991)

Lola Van Wagenen

Nuanced Scholarly Text held in the CorpusHeld in the Dialogue run.

That Latter-day Saint women were politically organized before enfranchisement, and the sequence linking the January 1870 mass meetings to the February 1870 suffrage act.

1991

"The Odyssey of a Latter-day Prophet: Wilford Woodruff," Journal of Mormon History 17 (1991)

Thomas G. Alexander

Neutral academic Scholarly Text held in the CorpusThe Journal of Mormon History is held complete for vols. 1–40 (1974–2014); cite the article, not the journal.

Woodruff's shift from apocalyptic expectation to a decision framed around saving the temples, and the political ground on which the Manifesto rested.

1991

"Twentieth-Century Polygamy and Fundamentalist Mormons in Southern Utah," Dialogue 24, no. 4 (Winter 1991)

Ken Driggs

Nuanced Scholarly Text held in the CorpusHeld in the Dialogue run; related Driggs pieces on Short Creek appear in Dialogue 23:2 and 38:1.

How the ambiguity of 1890–1904 produced the fundamentalist movement, and the text of the Utah constitutional ban on plural marriage.

2007

"The Reed Smoot Hearings," Journal of Mormon History 33, no. 2 (2007)

Harvard S. Heath

Neutral academic Scholarly Text held in the CorpusHeld in the JMH run.

The chronology, committee votes and political management of the four-year investigation, including the June 1906 committee report against Smoot.

FAIR, "Official Declaration Number 1" and "Plural marriage/Polygamy in the 19th Century"

FAIR

Faithful / apologetic Apologetic Text held in the CorpusBoth halves of fairlatterdaysaints.org are held; these are topical pages, not the rebuttal-compilation namespace.

The strongest faithful reading, including the argument that the Manifesto's first-person singular wording was deliberate and that leaders were placed in a double bind.

"New Light on the Lorin Woolley Story and Early Fundamentalist Beginnings" and related essays, josephsmithspolygamy.org

Brian C. Hales

Faithful / apologetic Apologetic Text held in the CorpusHales's site is held, including his analysis and reproduced documents; the 1886 text is separately reproduced in B. H. Roberts Foundation records.

The text of the 27 September 1886 document, the 1912 versus 1929 versions of Woolley's account, and the faithful case against the ordination claim.

MormonThink, "Polygamy" and "Lying for the Lord"

MormonThink; Ken Clark

Critical / secular Critical Text held in the CorpusMormonThink site pages and hosted PDFs are held.

The critical case that the Manifesto functioned as a public instrument while the practice continued, assembled largely from Quinn, Hardy and the Smoot Case transcripts.

1987

Mormonism—Shadow or Reality?

Jerald and Sandra Tanner

Evangelical counter-cult Critical Text held in the CorpusUtah Lighthouse Ministry books are held largely complete; chapters 16–17 cover plural marriage and the Manifesto.

Reproductions of Woodruff's 1891 master-in-chancery testimony and of Smoot Case exchanges, useful as a finding aid and checkable against the originals.

What this topic needs that the corpus does not hold

  • B. Carmon Hardy, Solemn Covenant: The Mormon Polygamous Passage (1992), and his documentary companion Doing the Works of Abraham — the standard study of post-Manifesto polygamy, cited constantly here and held nowhere; only a BYU Studies review notice and citation records are in the corpus.
  • Wilford Woodruff's journals (Kenney edition) and the Abraham H. Cannon, George Q. Cannon and Anthon H. Lund diaries — the private record on which nearly every claim in this topic depends, present only as quotations inside other works.
  • Proceedings before the Committee on Privileges and Elections in the Matter of the Protests against the Right of Hon. Reed Smoot (4 vols.) — the hearing transcripts themselves; the corpus holds Smoot's diaries but not the testimony.
  • The Deseret News, The Seer, the Woman's Exponent and the Millennial Star after 1859 — the contemporary Mormon press for this whole period, which means the 1852 Deseret News extra, Pratt's Washington periodical and the women's own newspaper are all reachable only through quotation.

Related topics

People who also appear elsewhere